Maine Coast Life’s guide to Portland lobster rolls
by Madison Ellingsworth
Everyone has an opinion on lobster rolls. Journalist Robin Catalano writes in National Geographic that this meaty delicacy gained popularity during the 1960s, when the rivalry between Connecticut's hot, buttery creation and Maine's cold, creamy version took off. Over the past 50 years, the lobster roll has remained largely unchanged, but every seafood spot has its own take. In Portland, there's a lobster roll for everyone.
Bite Into Maine: Always fresh
At just over $30, the cost of a Bite Into Maine lobster roll is competitively priced. However, price is the only ordinary thing about it. With six style options, including wasabi, curry, and chipotle mayonnaise, and two Portland locations (a brick-and-mortar on Diamond Street and a food truck at Allagash Brewing), Bite Into Maine offers something for every lobster lover. Most importantly, its lobster meat is never frozen, keeping every roll fresh and tender.
The High Roller Lobster Co: Eclectic alternatives
The High Roller Lobster Co. has adventurous eaters covered. Diners can choose from seven different mayonnaise options, two types of butter — including lobster ghee — and toppings ranging from Old Bay seasoning to fried chicken. At just over $30, the restaurant's build-your-own lobster rolls are competitively priced.
Those looking for a creative twist on the classic Maine favorite can also try lobster tacos, lobster grilled cheese, or the delightfully named Lobby Pops — lobster tails on a stick, available either deep-fried or drenched in butter.
Luke's Lobster Portland Pier and Dry Dock: Approachable and ample
A true traditional, down-to-earth Maine dining experience can be found at Luke's Lobster. With two Portland locations — Portland Pier and Dry Dock — Luke's has Commercial Street covered. Diners at the Dry Dock location can expect to pay about $35 for a lobster roll, while those at Portland Pier have the option to size up.
Available in 5-, 6-, and 8-ounce portions, Luke's lobster rolls range from about $30 to $52. Every order is served with Cape Cod potato chips and a dill pickle.
Eventide: Elevated eating
Eventide is best known for its James Beard Award-winning oyster bar, but its brown butter lobster roll deserves just as much attention. Sprinkled with diced chives and served on a steamed bun, this fresh take on a classic is inspired by the soft texture of traditional bao. At about $23, it is also one of Portland's most affordable lobster rolls.
Round out the meal with oysters on the half shell, kimchi or scallop waffle-yaki tempura.
J's Oyster Bar: Quintessentially Maine
Everything at J's Oyster is market price, and that includes their signature lobster roll. Since opening in 1977, J's has been a favorite among Portland fishermen. Over the years, it has become a community institution beloved by locals and visitors alike.
Its signature roll features fresh lobster and lettuce on a grilled brioche bun, served with potato chips, pickle chips, and your choice of mayonnaise or butter.
*
Portland's lobster roll scene offers something for every palate. Try a spicy wasabi roll at Bite Into Maine, order an 8-ounce classic at Luke's, or sample Eventide's affordable bao-style creation. If you're especially hungry, make a day of it and try them all. Just don't forget your lobster bib.
Which of these lobster rolls have you tried? We'd love to hear your favorites.