Back to News & Stories
    Nightlife

    25 Years Later, Rustic Overtones Celebrate “¡Viva Nueva!” With the New Kids

    By Maine Coast Life EditorsNovember 18, 2026

    Photos by Madeline Sullivan

    Written by Madeline Sullivan

    A line of people stood outside as Live at Madrid’s timeless black-and-white sign looked down on them. Some were couples, some were buddies hyped for the show, and a few were parents and their teens. What they all had in common were cuffed rain jackets as they braved the wet November day, waiting for the historic show brewing inside. As the sun started setting, the doors opened and Maine’s Rustic Overtones’ 25th anniversary show celebrating its acclaimed 2001 album, “¡Viva Nueva!” began.

    Madrid’s staff worked a $3 coat check and served everyone’s first drinks of the night. Showgoers perused the merch tables while others moved quickly to secure their viewing spots. At the end of a long, high-ceilinged room, the stage produced continuous fog, illuminated with heavy blue lighting. As patrons waited, songs by David Bowie, Echo & the Bunnymen and Neil Young kept everyone company over the venue’s speakers.

    Coming to the stage...

    The opening act, Bread, was a rapper using beats, samples and his voice to warm up the crowd. At the end of his last song, Rustic Overtones frontman Dave Gutter broke through the wall between opener and headliner to give the audience some background on Bread — or Joe, as he called him. A longtime friend of the late Rustic Overtones trombonist Dave Noyes, Joe was present throughout the recording of “¡Viva Nueva!” Gutter recalled how the band would go between recording with Bowie and making rap music in a second studio downstairs. After thanking Joe for coming out of retirement, Gutter joked about critics blaming the band’s embrace of hip-hop for ruining its career.

    Madrid’s was now full, with a capacity of around 800 people. Since opening in March, the venue has built buzz with heavy hitters like Built to Spill and Saving Abel, while making space for local headliners like Spose and the Fogcutters.

    Before the sea of people, My Guy appeared and started its funky, soul-jazz-fusion instrumental set. Creating a circle to the left of the stage, the band locked in with each other and established heavy backbeats, funk grooves and grounding percussion that swayed the room. Earlier in the evening, Gutter had described My Guy as one of his favorite local bands. During the final few songs, local R&B singer Angelikah Fahray came onstage and layered her sultry, silky, and dynamic vocals over the foundation My Guy had established. Gutter co-produced Fahray’s single “High Jump,” making her another Gutter-approved addition to the lineup.

    And now, for your headliner...

    Finally, Rustic Overtones hit the stage. The seven-piece band launched into “C’mon” without an introduction, and the crowd instantly chanted along. The blaring horn lines and sharp hooks showed why the band remains such a powerful live act. Gutter played an unbranded, custom yellow electric guitar for most of the set, but for “Smoke,” he whipped out sunglasses and shouted into a megaphone, tossing that energy toward original bassist Jon Roods. With a smile, Roods absorbed that chemistry and channeled it through his foundational bass lines, feeding it back to the rest of the band. Longtime saxophonist Jason Ward commanded attention with his electrifying solos. Jamie Colpoys’ punchy trombone playing fit seamlessly into the horn section, carrying forward the musical legacy of the late Dave Noyes. Drummer Gary Gemmiti kept the band charging forward with infectious enthusiasm, while alto saxophonist Lucas Desmond brought his own swagger to the arrangements. Their stage presence was confident and comfortable, fitting for a band celebrating an album that helped define its career.

    Later, Alma June joined Rustic Overtones onstage for “Baby Blue.” June, a genre-bending artist blending indie, alternative rock and jazz, also contributed the song to “Long Live the New,” a compilation featuring contemporary Maine artists reimagining “¡Viva Nueva!” Coordinated by Equal Measure Arts, the project reaches back and pulls forward parts of Maine’s music scene, highlighting upcoming artists while paying respect to those who paved the way.

    Before performing “Sector Z,” which features David Bowie on the original recording, Gutter announced that My Guy’s keyboardist, Myles Kelley, had never crowd-surfed before and gave him the opportunity to change that. Once Kelley was whisked away by the crowd, the band continued its set.

    Bridging generations of Maine musicians, the night offered a glimpse into the artistic community surrounding Gutter and Rustic Overtones, from longtime friends to a younger generation of collaborators. The anniversary celebrated the band’s history while giving the stage to artists helping write the next chapter of Maine music.

    Rustic Overtones setlist — Live at Madrid’s, Nov. 7, 2026

    1. “C’mon”

    2. “Gas”

    3. “Love Underground”

    4. “Hardest Way Possible”

    5. “Crash Landing”

    6. “Smoke”

    7. “Baby Blue” (with Alma June)

    8. “Revolution”

    9. “Sector Z”

    10. “Combustible”

    11. “Valentine’s Day Massacre”

    12. “Hit Man”

    13. “Check”

    14. “Boy and Girls”

    15. “Beekeeper”

    16. “Man Without a Mouth”

    Encore:

    17. “Rock Like War”

    18. “Black Shirt”

    19. “Light at the End”

    Rustic Overtones
    Live at Madrid
    Portland Music
    Local Bands
    Anniversary Show
    Nightlife
    Live Music
    Maine Music

    Share this article